Repair or Replacement: Which is Suitable for Your Door?

A door is the most critical barrier for blocking off the home’s entrance. Typically, they consist of a door frame and panels that swing, slide, or fold to allow entry or exit. Unfortunately, all these components are vulnerable to wear and tear over time. So, repairing or replacing it can be crucial to making your home safe and secure.

But always work with a reliable contractor to repair or replace your door today.

Door Repair vs Door Replacement

Deciding Factors in the Repair or Replacement Debate

Making a decision whether to repair or replace a door depends on many factors. Also, repairing the door can be cheaper than replacing the entire unit. But then, it is important to assess the level of damage keenly and consider the available options before deciding your next move.

Here are the most crucial factors to consider when making a door repair vs. replace debate:

  • Level of Damage. Doors can suffer from both minor and major damages due to various factors like pets, people, and weather changes. The severity of damage should guide your decision between door repair and replacement. Extensive damages, like cracked wooden frames or broken fiberglass door locks, often warrant replacement as repairs might not restore their strength. However, regular maintenance can suffice for minor issues like worn-out hinges, avoiding the need for replacement.
  • Budget Available. Budget is key in deciding to repair or replace doors. While some repairs might cost more than replacement, minor damages and noisy hinges can often be fixed cost-effectively. If affordable, invest in high-quality doors for durability and value. Conversely, replacing a basic steel door with a quality one can enhance safety, outweighing the cost of constant repairs.
  • Materials Used. The type of material used to make a door will also determine whether you need a door replaced or repaired. Today, doors are available in several designs and materials. The most common include stainless steel, classic wood, aluminum, lightweight fiberglass, industrial glass, and high-resistant vinyl. Replacing doors with easily-to-access accessories can be a great idea because you will not require expensive materials. On the contrary, replacing the entire glass door can be cheaper than repairing a shattered window pane because you might have to contact an expert door repair worker. Overall, the price of repairing materials like glass and fiberglass can be higher than replacing the entire frame.
  • Placement of Door. Door placement plays a key role in deciding between repair and replacement. Damaged exterior doors, especially if old or poorly insulated, often benefit more from replacement. Interior doors usually endure less damage and can be repaired feasibly. High-traffic areas need regular restoration for durability. However, minor issues like loose locks or hinges can be fixed easily without professional skills.
  • Desired Aesthetic. Door aesthetics involves color changes, frame redesigns, or lock updates. For minor damages like scratches or dents, repairs can restore the original look. However, if you’re aiming for a style overhaul, replacing an old door will modernize your home. Always choose a replacement that matches your preferred aesthetic.
door repair in GTA

When to Repair Doors

There are a few instances when you should repair a door. On most occasions, if the door starts to behave awkwardly or show signs of wear and tear. Here are the most common situations when a door refurbishment is necessary to guarantee longevity.

  1. Noise: It is time to repair your door and prevent further damage when you notice noise around the hinges or locks. Typically, you do not need to remove the hinges but oil them regularly or fix all the loose screws.
  2. Difficulty in opening or closing the door is also another sign that your door needs accessory renewal. Ordinarily, exterior doors are exposed to harsh weather conditions and insect damage. So, you must address these issues immediately by installing weatherstripping to seal air leaks. In addition, repaint the door with weatherproof paint or other recommended solutions to avoid severe impairment.
  3. Rust and corrosion on steel or aluminum doors need repainting or redecoration to prevent further damage and heighten your home’s aesthetic appearance.
  4. Minor damages: You can repair slight impairments like grazes, small impressions, or loose hardware with the recommended tools. Remember that repairing is a practical and cheap solution to maintain your door’s original look.
  5. Insufficient resources: If you have a limited budget or resources, repairing doors can help you achieve satisfying results and ensure enough security at home.

Pros vs Cons of Repairing Broken Door

There are four advantages of repairing a broken door.

  1. It is a cost-effective approach.
  2. Repairing a broken door maintains its original style and design.
  3. It is simple and quick.
  4. It reduces waste and conserves the available resources.

Repairing a broken door also has its disadvantages. These include:

  1. Repairing damages like rot or warp cannot be less effective.
  2. The door might require additional repairs in the future.
  3. Reduces the door’s functionality as it might not fully open or close.
  4. Repairs might affect the door’s aesthetic appearance.

When to Replace Doors

Your home’s security should be a top priority. Minor repairs and regular maintenance can prolong the lifespan of a door to prevent costly repairs or replacements. However, you cannot repair all damages. Instead, replacing the door may be necessary in some cases.

But here are several other reasons why you might need to replace your doors:

  1. Age deterioration: Severe wear and tear on a door can cause extensive damage and risk to your property. So, replacing the entire door will guarantee peace of mind.
  2. Significant cracking, warping, and rotting: With significant damage, replacing the door can be a practical and efficient option.
  3. Replacing your traditional doors with modern and more energy-efficient designs can help you reduce utility bills significantly.
  4. Aesthetic appearance: Replacing simple doors with advanced or quality models can improve your home’s look.
  5. Security: You can replace wooden doors with durable stainless steel or aluminum doors to boost security at home.

You must replace the door if it has extensive damage like rot, warp, or broken frame. Moreover, if the door is very old or outdated, replacing it can be a great option to improve its functionality, energy efficiency, and overall appearance.

Pros vs Cons of Replacing Broken Door

Replacing a broken door has its advantages and disadvantages. Here are four advantages and disadvantages.

Pros of replacing a broken door

  1. Replacing improves the overall door’s functionality.
  2. Modern door installation increases the energy efficiency of doors.
  3. It improves your home’s security.
  4. It improves the aesthetic appearance of your home.

Cons of replacing a broken door

  1. Replacing a broken door can be more expensive than repairing it.
  2. It requires more time and effort.
  3. There might be limited options in the market.
  4. Replacing a door requires additional materials or resources.


Doors complete the essential parts of the structural integrity of a building. Some doors will lead outside, and others can be inside the house. So, it is crucial to ensure they function efficiently and are in good condition. Remember that a damaged door may compromise the safety and security of your home or business, and replacing it should be necessary.

Generally, it’s always a good idea to consult with a professional door repairman to assess the condition of your doors and determine if replacement or repair is necessary.

At A+ Lock & Door, we have been replacing doors and repairing damaged components affordably. Call us at (416) 253-9615 for quick, reliable, and quality service.

Related Articles

How To Remove A Door Knob That Is Stuck

28 Apr 2022

Read More

How To Stop A Door From Opening On Its Own

28 Apr 2022

Read More

How to Repair an Exterior Door

30 Sep 2019

Read More

How to Repair Door Bell

29 Sep 2019

Read More